When Marcy Bradford dies, she leaves her teenage daughter, Nicole, in the custody of a father she never met; or rather, two fathers - Michael, a straight-laced and formal man, and Joey, a wild artist. Both were Marcy's ex-boyfriends, and together, they provide a unique balance of parenting skills for Nicole.
Zach, a boy whom Nicole knew moves to New York and comes to see her. And Cory...