Prim schoolteacher Miss Meadows (Katie Holmes) is not entirely what she appears. She is well-mannered, sweet, and caring, yes, but the candy-sweet exterior hides the soul of a vigilante who sets about righting the wrongs in this cruel world by whatever means necessary. Things get complicated, however, when Miss Meadows gets romantically entangled with the town sheriff (James Badge Dale) and her steadfast moral compass is thrown off, begging the question: "Who is the real Miss Meadows and what is she hiding?"